I am a thief, twice over.
I don't generally put items under the cart, but this day I put 2L of coke underneath and forgot about it. The cashier and the bagger also did not notice and so I left the store with it. I resolved to pay for it next time I was at that store.
Yesterday I was at that store. I told the cashier I had not paid for a 2L coke the last time I was there and that I wanted to pay for it now. She said nothing, so once she told me my total I asked if she had charged me for the coke. She informed me that she "could not do that" (my interpretation: "that seems like too much work").
When I got out to the car I found an unpaid for pack of wipes in Micah's lap. Great, now I have to fight to pay for two stolen items.
I have two ideas for how to resolve this situation: (1) Next time I'm there, select and pay for a coke and a pack of wipes, then give them back to the cashier for restocking. Risk being told I "can't do that". (2) Next time I'm there, select and pay for a coke and a pack of wipes, then give them to someone in need.
What would you do?